ACNS 2024

Usable Authentication in Virtual Reality: Exploring the Usability of PINs and Gestures

HTMA Riyadh, Divyanshu Bhardwaj, Adrian Dabrowski, Katharina Krombholz

In short

Virtual reality needs authentication that protects sensitive information without interrupting immersion. This study compares a familiar four-digit PIN pad with gesture-based authentication designed for three-dimensional interaction. In a study with 40 participants, gesture-based authentication achieved higher usability ratings and faster authentication times. Participants with less VR experience benefited particularly from the more natural interaction method.

How the study was done

  • 40 participants
  • Between-subjects study
  • PIN vs. mid-air gestures

We conducted a between-subjects user study with 40 participants. The study compared a conventional four-digit numeric PIN entered through a virtual keypad with four single-hand alphabetic gestures performed in three-dimensional space.

Key findings

  1. Traditional input

    Familiar PINs do not transfer seamlessly

    Although PINs are familiar from everyday devices, entering them in VR can be less usable and can interrupt the immersive interaction.

  2. Natural interaction

    Gestures were faster and easier to use

    Gesture-based authentication achieved higher usability scores and shorter authentication times than the two-dimensional PIN method.

  3. User experience

    VR newcomers benefited most

    Participants with less prior VR experience gained the greatest usability benefit from the natural gesture-based interaction.

  4. Design implication

    Use interaction native to VR

    The findings suggest designing authentication around spatial and gestural interaction instead of simply reproducing conventional number pads.

What should change

VR application designers should consider authentication methods that fit the environment’s native interaction capabilities. Gesture-based input can provide a more usable and faster experience than transferring familiar two-dimensional PIN interfaces into immersive settings.

Abstract

This study examines whether authentication methods designed for conventional screens remain usable in immersive virtual reality. In a between-subjects study with 40 participants, it compares a two-dimensional four-digit PIN pad with single-hand mid-air alphabetic gestures. Gesture-based authentication performed better on usability and speed, with the greatest benefit for participants who had less prior VR experience. The results support choosing interaction methods that fit the native capabilities of VR rather than directly transplanting familiar two-dimensional interfaces.

Cite this paper