CHI 2026

From Discovery to Decisions: Archetypal Journeys of Mobile App Users and Their Implications on Privacy

HTMA Riyadh, Divyanshu Bhardwaj, Maria Victoria Hellenthal, Alexander Hart, Katharina Krombholz, Sven Bugiel

In short

Research on app permissions usually looks at the moment a permission dialog appears. This study shows that the decision is shaped much earlier: by how people first hear about an app, how they compare and choose it, and how they install it. Each of these steps sets expectations that carry over to the moment they tap “Allow” or “Deny”.

How the study was done

  • 19 interviews
  • U.S. Android users
  • 4 archetypal journeys

We interviewed 19 Android users in the United States, selected through a screening survey on Prolific. Participants walked us through how they recognized a need for an app, found it, explored and chose it, installed it and answered its permission requests.

Key findings

  1. Recommended

    Trusted peers replace scrutiny

    When friends, family or colleagues recommend an app, people skip most of the evaluation and treat permission prompts as a routine confirmation.

  2. Mandatory

    Required apps leave no real choice

    Apps required by an employer or an essential service are installed as instructed. People voice concerns about permissions but cannot decline without losing access.

  3. Incentives

    Rewards outweigh privacy concerns

    Ads, coupons and loyalty points speed up the journey. Even people who are otherwise privacy-conscious accept permissions to get the reward.

  4. Sideloaded

    Community trust replaces the app store

    For apps from outside the Play Store, forums and experienced users take over the vetting role, and people accept a higher risk for the benefit.

What should change

Permission granting is a sequential, path-dependent process, not a single moment at the prompt. Privacy information such as the Data Safety Section often goes unnoticed because it appears too early. Platforms should show it at the moments that matter: key Data Safety details in the permission screen, short privacy summaries at installation, and reminders at first launch or when a sensitive feature is turned on. The paper’s framework also supports privacy-focused walkthroughs of the whole journey.

Common questions

How do people decide whether to allow app permissions?

Long before the permission prompt appears. In interviews with 19 Android users, the decision was shaped by how people first heard about an app, how they compared and chose it, and how they installed it. Each step set expectations that carried over to the moment they tapped “Allow” or “Deny”.

Why do people accept app permissions they are worried about?

When friends, family or colleagues recommend an app, people treat permission prompts as a routine confirmation. Apps required by an employer or an essential service leave no real choice. Ads, coupons and loyalty points also outweigh privacy concerns, even for people who are otherwise privacy-conscious.

Why do people miss privacy information such as the Data Safety section?

It often goes unnoticed because it appears too early in the journey. The paper recommends showing key Data Safety details in the permission screen, short privacy summaries at installation, and reminders at first launch or when a sensitive feature is turned on.

Abstract

Mobile permission decisions are often studied at the moment a permission request appears. However, our study shows that users’ choices are shaped much earlier, across a multi-stage journey that begins with app-need recognition and unfolds through app discovery, exploration, selection, installation, and first use. Drawing on interviews with 19 U.S. Android users, we map this process and identify four archetypal journeys that explain how early cues, such as discovery sources, app type, and social trust, shape later permission behavior. These insights align with theoretical models like Privacy Calculus, showing how users weigh perceived benefits and risks at each step, and complement Contextual Integrity theory, explaining how social norms and information flows shape expectations and constrain privacy agency across steps. We contribute an empirically grounded framework that clarifies why permission outcomes vary across contexts. Our results reframe mobile privacy as a sequential, path-dependent process, offering implications for future design and research.

Cite this paper