In Focus, Out of Privacy: The Wearer’s Perspective on the Privacy Dilemma of Camera Glasses
In short
Camera glasses such as Ray-Ban Stories can take photos and videos from the wearer’s point of view, often without the people nearby noticing. That challenges social norms about recording bystanders. This is the first study of the wearers’ own perspective: how they deal with the privacy of the people around them while wearing the glasses.
How the study was done
- 15 participants
- 2-week diary study
- Exit interviews
We ran a micro-longitudinal diary study with 15 participants, existing camera glasses users and people with no prior experience. For two weeks they wore camera glasses and reported their privacy-related experiences on the go through an instant messenger, followed by semi-structured exit interviews.
Key findings
- Indicators
Privacy indicators fall short
Wearers consider the privacy indicators currently available on camera glasses ineffective.
- Design
The camera is hard to spot
Wearers believe the look and interaction design of the glasses conceal the technology from people who are unaware of it.
- Burden
Wearers carry the responsibility
Without effective ways to mediate privacy, wearers feel emotionally burdened with protecting bystanders’ privacy.
- Use
It changes how they use them
This sense of burden affects how wearers use their camera glasses.
What should change
Both technical and non-technical solutions are needed. Consent negotiation and better-tuned privacy indicators are the key challenges for using camera glasses in a privacy-preserving way. The paper also compares wearers’ and bystanders’ perspectives and maps the design space for a privacy-preserving ecosystem of wearable cameras.
Common questions
Can people tell when camera glasses are recording?
Often not. The wearers in our two-week diary study considered the privacy indicators currently available on camera glasses ineffective. They also believed the look of the glasses conceals the camera from people who are unaware of the technology.
What are the privacy concerns with smart glasses?
Camera glasses can take photos and videos from the wearer’s point of view, often without the people nearby noticing, which challenges social norms about recording bystanders. Without effective ways to mediate privacy, wearers felt emotionally burdened with protecting bystanders’ privacy, and this changed how they used the glasses.
How could smart glasses become more privacy-friendly?
The paper concludes that both technical and non-technical solutions are needed. Consent negotiation and better-tuned privacy indicators are the key challenges for using camera glasses in a privacy-preserving way.
Abstract
The rising popularity of camera glasses challenges societal norms of recording bystanders and thus requires efforts to mediate privacy preferences. We present the first study on the wearers’ perspectives and explore privacy challenges associated with wearing camera glasses when bystanders are present. We conducted a micro-longitudinal diary study (N = 15) followed by exit interviews with existing users and people without prior experience. Our results show that wearers consider the currently available privacy indicators ineffective. They believe the looks and interaction design of the glasses conceal the technology from unaware people. Due to the lack of effective privacy-mediating measures, wearers feel emotionally burdened with preserving bystanders’ privacy. We furthermore elicit how this sentiment impacts their usage of camera glasses and highlight the need for technical and non-technical solutions. Finally, we compare the wearers’ and bystanders’ perspectives and discuss the design space of a future privacy-preserving ecosystem for wearable cameras.
Cite this paper
@inproceedings{10.1145/3613904.3642242,
author = {Bhardwaj, Divyanshu and Ponticello, Alexander and Tomar, Shreya and Dabrowski, Adrian and Krombholz, Katharina},
title = {In Focus, Out of Privacy: The Wearer's Perspective on the Privacy Dilemma of Camera Glasses},
year = {2024},
isbn = {9798400703300},
publisher = {Association for Computing Machinery},
address = {New York, NY, USA},
url = {https://doi.org/10.1145/3613904.3642242},
doi = {10.1145/3613904.3642242},
abstract = {The rising popularity of camera glasses challenges societal norms of recording bystanders and thus requires efforts to mediate privacy preferences. We present the first study on the wearers’ perspectives and explore privacy challenges associated with wearing camera glasses when bystanders are present. We conducted a micro-longitudinal diary study (N = 15) followed by exit interviews with existing users and people without prior experience. Our results show that wearers consider the currently available privacy indicators ineffective. They believe the looks and interaction design of the glasses conceal the technology from unaware people. Due to the lack of effective privacy-mediating measures, wearers feel emotionally burdened with preserving bystanders’ privacy. We furthermore elicit how this sentiment impacts their usage of camera glasses and highlight the need for technical and non-technical solutions. Finally, we compare the wearers’ and bystanders’ perspectives and discuss the design space of a future privacy-preserving ecosystem for wearable cameras.},
booktitle = {Proceedings of the 2024 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems},
articleno = {577},
numpages = {18},
keywords = {camera glasses, privacy, smart glasses, wearables, wearer’s perspective},
location = {Honolulu, HI, USA},
series = {CHI '24}
}